The Intelligence Collaborative

A collective of professionals and passionate amateurs around the globe who analyze a world in transition and help guide leaders in their most critical decisions.

CI - implications of Crowdsourcing

Dear Group members,

 

I recently read some interesting insights on Crowdsourcing, a practice that Wikipedia defines as "the act of outsourcing tasks, traditionally performed by an employee or contractor to a large group of people or community (a crowd) through an open call". The key in crowdsourcing is to break down a specific task into small chunks of work that can be performed by a relevant established professional (or knowledgeable amateur) in his spare time for the benefit or a larger organization.

 

This type of practice has already been used in Marketing activities such as when a company wants to design a new t-shirt it makes an open call for submissions from web users. Crowdsourcing has also been used in writing code in software production. A more hypothetical example would be that a CI - professional would crowdsource parts of a background investigation into a competitor so that someone would do financial due diligence. another value chain analysis, another competitive positioning analysis etc... There are no immediate arguments that come to my mind why this sort of practice could not be used in industrial manufacturing, too, at some point in the process.

 

Crowdsourcing is not a subject without controversy, not least because of the implications it has for the world of work. But I started to think more deeply about the fact that the crowdsourcing assignments are sought through an "open call". More specific questions that came to my mind are: How open is the call for submissions? How much signals about its intentions does the company give away by submitting the open call, although the assignment is broken down into smaller tasks that do not necessarily give away the whole plan? How can companies utilize crowdsourcing without giving away too much information about its intentions? How can competitive intelligence professionals get intel on the intentions of competitors by mining open calls for crowdsourcing assignments? How can that be done ethically?

 

Maybe some of you have already come across crowdsourcing as a phenomenon, and maybe also the CI-implications of crowdsourcing. It would be interesting to discuss this topic here on the IntelCollab.

 

Best regards,

Ari

 

PS. The Wikipedia-entry on "Crowdsourcing" to which I referred above can be found under:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crowdsourcing

Load Previous Replies
  • up

    Arik Johnson

    Hi all,

    I've (finally) gotten the June 25th Intel Collab teleconference scheduled into our GotoMeeting account and we're ready to take registrations. We're on for Friday 25 June at 10:30 eastern. Panelists include Ari, Monica, Ellen Seena and Annette. Hope you can all still make that time and apologies it took me a few days to get it officially scheduled. Here's the registration URL for non-panelists to join the discussion:

    https://www2.gotomeeting.com/register/906333651

    I'll be adding this as an official event to share with All Members today as well.

    - Arik
    2
    • up

      Arik Johnson

      Many thanks to everyone, panelists in particular, who joined us on the Intel Collab telecon this morning (25 June). Which upcoming Friday in July would you like to take the conversation up again? We're booked for July 2 to discuss an update to the CI Wiki project, but then nothing in particular in scheduled from there.

      I copied possible agenda items from the Wave for this call and might've gotten some of this wrong, so please correct me.

      Topics for next time:

      - Case studies of Crowdsourcing for its Application in Innovation (Valerie)
      - Development of Company Policy & Terms and Conditions (Ari)
      - Players in the Market Space (Monica)
      - Effectiveness Measures (Seena)

      What'd I miss?

      Finally, I'll be uploading the recording for review later today to:

      http://files.aurorawdc.com/arikjohnson/20100625_intelcollab.wmv

      It's sure to be a big file but feel free to remix and share as you like.

      Happy weekend and looking forward to our next discussion!

      Cheers,

      - Arik
      4
    • up

      Ari Korpinen

      Hello,

      In the teleconference on Crowdsourcing on the 25 June a suggestion was made that we would continue the lively discussion in another teleconference during July. Arik got back to me today and suggested either 16 July or 23 July for the next teleconference on this topic.

      Is the group still interested in continuing discussing crowdsourcing and if so, is one of the above dates suitable for you?

      All the best,
      Ari